Tools for the People › Wildfire-code scorecard
Wildfire-code scorecard
A request anyone can copy and send, in your own name, asking California for a public scorecard of whether the wildfire building rules worked — and a board for the answers.
A We The People Scissors & Keys tool. Built Nov 10, 2026 (America/Los_Angeles). Not legal advice.
My question is simple: these are our tax dollars. They should really serve the safety and security of our building codes. Who holds the pen? And why is there no public scorecard I can find that says whether the wildfire code saved the houses?
Here is the record, beside that question — not a verdict, and not proof of anyone’s intent.
- In the 2025-26 Enacted budget, six California code programs add up to $325.2 million in public money (California Building Standards Commission, Housing and Community Development Codes and Standards, Office of the State Fire Marshal, Division of the State Architect, Coastal Commission, and Department of Health Care Access and Information Facilities Development). Source: California ebudget displays opened in our Nov 10, 2026 building-codes research.
- Around the same codes, seven documented companies show about $323.4 billion in latest-year revenue. That is company and insurer revenue. It is not tax dollars. It is not a measure of who holds the pen, and it is not proof of anyone’s intent. Source: the same research file, from 10-Ks and annual reports opened Nov 10, 2026 (7 of 17 company rows; mixed definitions).
- FEMA’s June 2025 Building Code Adoption Tracking sheet rates California “Higher Resistance” — on paper, for code adoption, not a wildfire-outcome score. Source: FEMA Region 9 fact sheet, June 2025, opened in that research.
- California already publishes Damage Inspection (DINS) data. The public file has a “Year Built (parcel)” field, and it includes the Camp Fire (2018) and the Palisades and Eaton fires (2025). Year built is a parcel join, not a Chapter 7A code edition. What we have not found is a state report that uses that file to say whether the wildfire code worked. ⚠ We did not search every office or archive. Official catalog: data.ca.gov — CAL FIRE DINS. Our own counts are on the check-it-yourself guide.
So this tool gives anyone a letter to send, in your own name, under the California Public Records Act. Ask the Office of the State Fire Marshal (CAL FIRE) and the California Building Standards Commission: show us the scorecard — or say, in writing, that you do not track it.
I will publish every answer we get, including no-records answers.
✂ Your one action
Copy one letter on this tool, send it in your own name, and bring the answer back to https://t.me/criticalthinkingisnotdead. Start with the state letter below if you are asking California. Use the county, Title 24, or insurance letter if that is your question.
Answers board
When answers come in, they will be listed here. Louisa updates this board herself. Nothing is posted yet.
If you send a request, you may share the agency’s answer with us at https://t.me/criticalthinkingisnotdead. Tell us whether we may publish your first name, or list you as “anonymous.” Do not send us your home address, phone number, or other private contact details to put on this page. We will not post private contact information.
| Who sent | Agency | Date sent | Date answered | What came back | Link to the response |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| No answers posted yet. When the first one arrives, this row will be replaced with a first name or “anonymous” (with consent), the agency, the dates, what came back (records / partial / “we don’t track this” / no reply), and a link to the response. | |||||
How to send the state letter
Send the same letter twice: once to the Office of the State Fire Marshal (through CAL FIRE), and once to the California Building Standards Commission (through the Department of General Services). Each agency should answer for the records it holds. Ask for electronic copies. Keep your request number and the date you sent it.
- Office of the State Fire Marshal / CAL FIRE. Preferred: the CAL FIRE Public Records Center (GovQA): https://calfire.govqa.us/WEBAPP/_rs/. Official guidelines: https://www.fire.ca.gov/about/resources/california-public-records. Or mail: CAL FIRE Legal Office, PO Box 944246, Sacramento, CA 94244-2460. Create or use a portal login, paste the letter, and submit. (Official pages opened Nov 10, 2026.)
- California Building Standards Commission / Department of General Services. The DGS Public Records Portal (GovQA; an account login is required): https://dgsca.govqa.us/WEBAPP/_rs/. Official CBSC instructions: https://www.dgs.ca.gov/BSC/Contact. Official DGS PRA page: https://www.dgs.ca.gov/Services/Page-Content/Service-List/Request-Public-Records-at-DGS. Questions about the portal: cbsc@dgs.ca.gov or (916) 263-0916. Create a portal account, paste the letter, and submit. (Official pages opened Nov 10, 2026.)
The 10-day rule in Government Code section 7922.535 is the time for the agency to determine whether disclosable records exist and to notify you, not a guarantee that every file will be produced in 10 days. In unusual circumstances the agency may extend that time by up to 14 days, in writing. Official text: Gov. Code §7922.535 (opened Nov 10, 2026). Short title of the Act: Gov. Code §7920.000.
When an answer comes back — including a “we don’t track this” or a no-records letter — please bring it to https://t.me/criticalthinkingisnotdead so it can be added to the board.
Copy-and-send letter (state agencies)
Fill in the [BRACKETS]. Use this in your own name. Do not add anyone else’s personal details.
Download the letter as a .txt file
[Date]
Public Records Act request
To:
Office of the State Fire Marshal
Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CAL FIRE)
Submitted through the CAL FIRE Public Records Center and/or
CAL FIRE Legal Office
PO Box 944246
Sacramento, CA 94244-2460
and
California Building Standards Commission
Department of General Services
Submitted through the DGS Public Records Portal
2525 Natomas Park Drive, Suite 130
Sacramento, California 95833
Re: Public records — wildfire / Chapter 7A code results and spending
Dear Public Records Officer:
Under the California Public Records Act, Government Code section 7920.000 and following, I request copies of the public records described below. Please send electronic copies if you have them in electronic form.
Government Code section 7922.535 requires that, within 10 days of receiving this request, the agency determine whether the request seeks disclosable public records in its possession and promptly notify me of that determination and the reasons for it. If the request seeks disclosable records, please also state the estimated date and time when the records will be made available.
I am asking for a public scorecard of whether California's wildfire building rules worked, and what was spent to adopt and enforce them. Please search records in the possession of your agency, including the Office of the State Fire Marshal if you are responding for CAL FIRE, and the California Building Standards Commission if you are responding for the Commission.
Please provide:
1. Records that show how many structures built under each wildfire (Chapter 7A / Wildland-Urban Interface) code edition since 2008 were damaged, destroyed, or survived in each major fire, including the Camp Fire (2018) and the Palisades and Eaton fires (2025). If Damage Inspection (DINS) data exists by year built, or by code edition, please include that analysis or those workbooks, reports, maps, and summaries.
I already know that CAL FIRE's public DINS dataset includes a field called "Year Built (parcel)," and that the public file includes incident records named Camp (start date Nov 8, 2018), Palisades (start date Jan 7, 2025), and Eaton (start date Jan 7, 2025). That field is a parcel join, not a Chapter 7A edition. This request is not a request that you resend that public file. It is a request for any records that analyze those inspections by year built or by wildfire-code edition, and for any records that identify whether a structure was built under Chapter 7A or a later WUI edition.
2. Any analysis, evaluation, study, or report, whether published or internal, of whether the Chapter 7A / WUI building standards worked — including findings that the standards reduced damage or loss, findings that they did not, and findings that the question could not be answered.
3. Records that show spending on adopting and enforcing WUI / Chapter 7A codes, including budgets, expenditures, grants, contracts, and staff or program cost displays for those functions, for fiscal years 2008-09 through 2025-26, if held by your agency.
If you do not track this, please say so in writing.
If some records are already posted, please send the exact public URL and still answer whether an analysis or spending record exists beyond that posting. If you withhold any record, please name the exemption and release all reasonably separable non-exempt portions.
If this request is too broad in any part, please contact me in writing and help me narrow it.
Thank you.
Sincerely,
[Your name]
[Your email]
[Optional phone]
[Optional mailing address]
[Optional: "I would like a copy of any request number you assign."]
Other letters and the DINS guide
- Check the public DINS file yourself — step by step, with our Nov 10, 2026 count as an example, clearly labeled as our count from the file, not an official finding.
- A county / city / fire-district version of the letter, with San Mateo County as the worked example of where to send it.
- A letter asking what free public access exists to California’s building code (Title 24), and what the publisher agreements cost.
- A letter to the California Department of Insurance asking whether wildfire-safer homes got lower rates or kept coverage.
General information, not legal advice. You file in your own name. ⚠ = not verified from a primary page opened for this tool, or a limit of what we opened. Pages and numbers on this tool were prepared Nov 10, 2026 (America/Los_Angeles).