Tools for the People › Wildfire-code scorecard › Insurance letter
Letter: did wildfire-safer homes get lower rates or keep coverage?
Ask the California Department of Insurance for records on Safer from Wildfires discounts, how many policyholders received them, non-renewals, and FAIR Plan discounts.
A fill-in letter to the California Department of Insurance. Prepared Nov 10, 2026 (America/Los_Angeles). Not legal advice.
Safer building rules matter more if a safer house can also get insurance, or a lower rate. This letter asks the Department whether its records show that happening.
What we opened, Nov 10, 2026
- The Department’s Safer from Wildfires page says: “Every action under Safer from Wildfires will qualify you for an insurance discount. By doing more, you can save more.” It links “the full text of the new Safer from Wildfires insurance regulation.” Official page: https://www.insurance.ca.gov/01-consumers/200-wrr/safer-from-wildfires.cfm.
- The regulation those materials point to is California Code of Regulations, title 10, section 2644.9, “Consideration of Mitigation Factors; Wildfire Risk Models.” A Legal Information Institute copy of that section (opened Nov 10, 2026) lists mandatory community-level and property-level mitigation factors that certain rating plans must take into account, and cites California Register 2022, No. 41. https://www.law.cornell.edu/regulations/california/10-CCR-2644.9. The Department’s own FAQ, dated Sep 4, 2026, also cites CCR §2644.9 and says a rating plan must contain a separate discount or credit for each mandatory mitigation factor, and that the Department expects consumers to receive at least $1 in premium reduction for each mandatory factor: Department FAQ (PDF, Sep 4, 2026).
- That is the Department’s rule and its consumer-facing statement. It is not, by itself, a count of how many policyholders received a discount, or of who was renewed or non-renewed. That is what the letter asks. ⚠ We did not open an official California FAIR Plan discount schedule in this pass, so this page does not recite unofficial percentage claims. The letter asks the Department for FAIR Plan discount records.
Where to send it
The Department’s Contact Us page (opened Nov 10, 2026) says people requesting information related to the Public Records Act should direct correspondence to the Legal Division, and it links the Department’s Guidelines for Accessing Public Records. Official page: https://www.insurance.ca.gov/0500-about-us/05-contact/ (anchor #PRA). The guidelines PDF, also opened that day, says to contact the Custodian of Records by mail, phone, or email:
- California Department of Insurance, Custodian of Records, 300 Capitol Mall, Suite 1700, Sacramento, CA 95814
- Phone: (916) 492-3657
- Email: CustodianOfRecords@insurance.ca.gov
Guidelines PDF: https://www.insurance.ca.gov/0500-about-us/05-contact/upload/Guidelines-for-Accessing-Public-Records.pdf. ⚠ That PDF still cites the older Government Code section numbers (6253 and 6253.4). The current 10-day determination rule is Government Code section 7922.535. Our letter uses the current numbering.
The 10-day rule is the time to determine whether disclosable records exist and to notify you, not a promise that every file arrives in 10 days. Unusual circumstances may add up to 14 days, in writing.
Download the letter as a .txt file
[Date]
Public Records Act request
To:
California Department of Insurance
Legal Division, Government Law Bureau
Custodian of Records
300 Capitol Mall, Suite 1700
Sacramento, CA 95814
CustodianOfRecords@insurance.ca.gov
Re: Public records — whether wildfire-safer homes received lower rates or kept coverage
Dear Custodian of Records:
Under the California Public Records Act, Government Code section 7920.000 and following, I request copies of the public records described below. Please send electronic copies if you have them in electronic form.
Government Code section 7922.535 requires that, within 10 days of receiving this request, the agency determine whether the request seeks disclosable public records in its possession and promptly notify me of that determination and the reasons for it. If the request seeks disclosable records, please also state the estimated date and time when the records will be made available.
The Department's own Safer from Wildfires page states that actions under that program "will qualify you for an insurance discount." California Code of Regulations, title 10, section 2644.9 requires, in the text we have read, that certain insurer rating plans take into account listed community-level and property-level wildfire mitigation factors. I am asking whether the Department's records show that wildfire-safer homes actually received lower rates or kept coverage.
Please provide:
1. Records of insurer rate filings, including approved rating plans and exhibits, that provide a premium discount or credit for wildfire mitigation measures under California Code of Regulations, title 10, section 2644.9, or under the Department's Safer from Wildfires program, from the effective date of that regulation to the present.
2. Records that show the number of policyholders who received those mitigation discounts or credits, by year if that breakdown is held, and any records that show the dollar amount of those discounts or credits in the aggregate.
3. Records of non-renewal, cancellation, or new-business declination data by wildfire mitigation status, if the Department collects or receives that information, including any summaries, reports, or data displays.
4. Records that show whether the California FAIR Plan offers, and how many policyholders received, wildfire mitigation discounts or credits, and any Department reviews or filings on that subject.
If you do not track this, please say so in writing.
If some records are already posted, including in the Department's Virtual Viewing Room or in public rate-filing systems, please send the exact public URL and still answer whether a record or a count exists beyond that posting. If you withhold any record, please name the exemption and release all reasonably separable non-exempt portions. I understand that some records may need names or other personal information redacted; I am asking for counts, filings, and summaries, not for a list of individual policyholders.
If this request is too broad in any part, please contact me in writing and help me narrow it.
Thank you.
Sincerely,
[Your name]
[Your email]
[Optional phone]
[Optional mailing address]
[Optional: "I would like a copy of any request number you assign."]
Bring answers, including “we do not track this,” back to https://t.me/criticalthinkingisnotdead.
✂ Your one action
Send the letter in your own name, and bring the answer back.
General information, not legal advice. You file in your own name. ⚠ = not verified from a primary page opened for this tool, or a limit of what we opened. Pages and numbers on this tool were prepared Nov 10, 2026 (America/Los_Angeles).