Scissors › Guide #3
Everyday Scissors #3: Dispute a Utility Bill (California)
✂ Do it now
Copy your letter below, then open the official page and file in your own name.
City, county or district water and sewer bills (Path B) don't go to the CPUC. Use the dispute or appeal steps on your bill or your agency's official website. Behind on bills? See Keys to grants & help for CARE/FERA and LIHEAP.
Links open official government pages. Checked Mon Oct 26, 2026 (PT).
We The People Scissors & Keys guide. Prepared Mon Oct 26, 2026 (PT). Every source below was opened that day. ⚠ = not verified yet.
What it is
A free, step-by-step way to challenge a wrong gas, electric, water or sewer bill, and keep your service on while you do it.
Who can use it
Any residential or business customer. There are two paths: - Path A: investor-owned utilities regulated by the CPUC, such as PG&E, SCE, SDG&E and SoCalGas. - Path B: city, county or district water and sewer agencies. The CPUC doesn't regulate these.
Path A: PG&E and other CPUC-regulated utilities
Step 1. Contact the utility first (free)
- Call or write and say clearly: "I dispute this bill." Ask for a written explanation and a meter re-check.
- Write down the date, time, rep's name and reference number.
- PG&E Electric Rule 11: if a residential customer starts a complaint within five days of receiving a disputed bill, PG&E won't shut off service until the dispute has been reviewed under Rule 10. You must keep paying later, undisputed bills. Act fast.
Step 2. Informal complaint to the CPUC (no fee listed)
If the utility doesn't fix it, go to the CPUC's Consumer Affairs Branch (CAB): - Online: cpuc.ca.gov → File a Complaint - Phone: 1-800-649-7570 (Mon–Fri, 8:30–4:30) - Fax: 1-415-703-1158 - Mail: CPUC Consumer Affairs Branch, 505 Van Ness Ave, San Francisco, CA 94102-3298
A written complaint becomes an "Informal Complaint." If your service is about to be shut off, call CAB right away.
Step 3. Keep the lights on: deposit the disputed amount with the CPUC
Under PG&E Electric Rule 10: - Instead of paying the disputed amount to PG&E, you may deposit it with the CPUC. Make the check payable to the CPUC. - No shutoff while your deposit and the CPUC review are pending. - Can't afford it? A residential customer who can't pay the full disputed amount isn't required to deposit it during the Commission's review. Tell CAB this. - Keep paying your new, undisputed bills on time. If new bills also seem wrong, dispute them the same way. If you don't, you can be disconnected. - The CPUC won't hold deposits for complaints that aren't about bill accuracy, such as service quality or rate levels. - ⚠ Other utilities have their own "Rule 10." The rules are similar, but check your utility's tariff.
Your shutoff protections (CPUC FAQ): - A bill isn't overdue until 19 days after it's sent. - Before a shutoff, the utility must send a 15-day written notice, then a 48-hour second notice. - No shutoffs on weekends or holidays (safety emergencies aside). - A deposit to start service can't be more than 2× your average monthly bill.
Step 4. Formal complaint (no filing fee, but public)
If CAB's answer doesn't solve it: - No filing fee. The CPUC's directions say: "We do not charge fees for filing a formal complaint." - Expedited procedure for disputes under $10,000 filed by a person (under $5,000 for a business or group): - no lawyers on either side; - the utility answers in 20 days; - the hearing is usually held within 30 days of that answer. - Regular procedure: any amount, and the answer is due in 30 days. - The formal complaint becomes public record. - The CPUC can't award damages. It can order the utility to fix the bill or follow its rules. - You have to prove the utility broke its tariff, a CPUC order or the law. - The CPUC may send you back to CAB first. - Help: CPUC Public Advisor, public.advisor@cpuc.ca.gov, 1-866-849-8390. - ⚠ The Rules of Practice section number for complaints (20 CCR §4.6) was seen in search only.
Path B: City, county or district water and sewer
- Agency appeal. - Call or write the billing office for [YOUR CITY/COUNTY]. Ask for a meter re-read, a leak check, and the written bill-dispute or appeal procedure. - ⚠ Deadlines, leak-adjustment policies and appeal steps differ by agency and weren't verified. Get them in writing.
- Know the Prop 218 limits (California Constitution, Article XIII D, §6). For property-related fees such as water and sewer: - The fee can't be more than the cost of providing the service, and the money can't be used for something else. - If it goes to court, the agency has the burden of proving the fee is legal (XIII D §6(b)(5): "In any legal action contesting the validity of a fee or charge"). - New or higher fees need a mailed notice to owners and a public hearing at least 45 days later. If a majority files written protests, the fee can't be imposed. - Prop 218 is about the rate itself, not a single wrong meter reading. Use it when the rate is the problem: show up at the hearing and file a written protest.
- Shutoff protection. ⚠ California also has a water-shutoff protection law for larger systems (SB 998, Water Shutoff Protection Act). It wasn't checked yet, so verify the details with your agency.
Cost
- The CPUC says it does "not charge fees for filing a formal complaint." Its CAB pages list no fee for an informal complaint.
- A CPUC deposit is the disputed amount, and you get it back if you win. Residential customers who can't afford it don't have to pay it.
Common mistakes
- Not paying anything. Pay the undisputed part and all new bills.
- Calling without keeping notes or reference numbers.
- Paying the disputed amount to the utility instead of depositing it with the CPUC.
- Using the deposit process for non-billing problems, which the CPUC won't accept.
- Missing the Prop 218 hearing, which is the one time a written protest can block a rate increase.
Fill-in template: written dispute (utility first, then CAB)
[YOUR FULL NAME]
[Service address] Account No.: [__________]
[Phone / email]
[Date]
To: [PG&E / utility name] Customer Service
cc (if unresolved): CPUC Consumer Affairs Branch, 505 Van Ness Ave,
San Francisco, CA 94102-3298
RE: Disputed bill dated [__/__/____] – Amount in dispute: $[______]
I dispute the bill above because:
[ ] Usage is far above my normal (avg. $[___]/month; this bill $[___])
[ ] Estimated or misread meter
[ ] Wrong rate plan / charges I did not authorize
[ ] Other: [explain]
Attached: [past bills, meter photos with dates, etc.].
Please (1) review and correct the bill in writing, and (2) confirm that
service will not be disconnected while this dispute is pending.
If this is not resolved, I will file an informal complaint with the CPUC
and deposit the disputed amount with the Commission under the utility's
Rule 10. [If applicable: I am a residential customer and cannot pay the
full disputed amount.] I will keep paying undisputed charges on time.
Thank you,
_________________________
[YOUR FULL NAME]
Sources (all opened Mon Oct 26, 2026, PT)
- CPUC, "How the Consumer Affairs Branch Can Help": https://www.cpuc.ca.gov/consumer-support/file-a-complaint/utility-complaint/how-the-consumer-affairs-branch-can-help
- CPUC, FAQs about utility complaints (19 days, 15-day and 48-hour notices, deposits): https://www.cpuc.ca.gov/consumer-support/file-a-complaint/utility-complaint/cab-faqs
- PG&E Electric Rule No. 10, Disputed Bills (sheet effective May 17, 2025): https://www.pge.com/tariffs/assets/pdf/tariffbook/ELEC_RULES_10.pdf
- PG&E Electric Rule No. 11, Discontinuance and Restoration of Service (billing dispute, five days), opened Oct 26, 2026: https://www.pge.com/tariffs/assets/pdf/tariffbook/ELEC_RULES_11.pdf
- CPUC, "Filing a Formal Complaint": https://www.cpuc.ca.gov/consumer-support/file-a-complaint/filing-a-formal-complaint
- CPUC Formal Complaint Directions and Form (expedited vs. regular, no fee): https://www.cpuc.ca.gov/-/media/cpuc-website/files/uploadedfiles/cpuc_website/content/about_us/organization/divisions/news_and_outreach_office/pao/documents/formal_process/formalcomplaintdirectionsandform091214.pdf
- Cal. Const. art. XIII D §6 (Prop 218), opened Oct 26, 2026 for the Scissors research notes (Lever 11): https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=CONS§ionNum=SEC.%206.&article=XIII%20D
Not legal advice. Know your rights. No lawsuits needed.