Tools for the People › Law B

Where official definitions get set: explainer + FOIA/CPRA templates for "show me how this definition was made"

KOEB Tools for the People · built Nov 2, 2026 (PT). Not legal advice. ⚠ = not verified from a primary page.

Who it's for: Anyone tracing who wrote a definition. Your one action: Pick one definition that affects you, find which channel set it, and send the matching FOIA or records request template this week.


What's really going on

A word like "hemp," "dwelling," or "fire-resistant" means whatever the controlling text says it means. That text is written through a handful of channels, and each one leaves a paper trail: - bills - notice-and-comment rules - guidance memos - emergency orders - private standards that governments adopt

If you know the channel, you know which paper trail to ask for, and when you could have commented.

The channels (citation + plain words + hemp or building example)

# Channel Primary citation (opened Nov 2, 2026 unless noted) Plain words Hemp or building example
1 Statute (Congress or Legislature) e.g., 7 U.S.C. §1639o as amended by P.L. 119-37 §781 (Nov 12, 2025): https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/PLAW-119publ37/html/PLAW-119publ37.htm Elected lawmakers write the definition into law. It changes only by a new law. The paper trail is bill text, committee reports, and hearings, which are not reachable by FOIA. Congress is exempt from FOIA; ask members directly. "Hemp" becomes ≤0.3% total THC, "includes industrial hemp" (stalk, fiber, grain). The law also ordered FDA to publish cannabinoid lists within 90 days. CRS reports none had been published as of Oct 28, 2026. California's own definition already uses total THC (HSC §11018.5(a)(2), as amended by AB 8, effective Jan 1, 2026).
2 Agency rule (notice and comment) 5 U.S.C. §553(b)–(e): notice in the Federal Register; "opportunity to participate... through submission of written data, views, or arguments"; a "concise general statement of their basis and purpose"; publication ≥30 days before the effective date; and (e) "the right to petition for the issuance, amendment, or repeal of a rule." https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2023-title5/html/USCODE-2023-title5-partI-chap5-subchapII-sec553.htm The agency proposes, the public comments, and the agency must answer comments in the final rule. Comments and the docket are public on regulations.gov. California has its own APA (Gov. Code §11340 et seq.). USDA's hemp rule, 7 CFR Part 990. Interim rule 84 FR 58522 (Oct 31, 2019); final rule 86 FR 5596 (Jan 19, 2021, effective Mar 22, 2021). It sets "Total THC" testing and sampling. California's analog is CDFA, 3 CCR §4890 (definitions, OAL approval Aug 29, 2024).
3 Guidance / interpretive statements §553(b)(A) exempts "interpretative rules, general statements of policy" from notice and comment, and §553(d)(2) from the 30-day wait. In California, Gov. Code §11340.5(a) bars any "guideline, criterion, bulletin, manual" that is really a regulation unless it was adopted as one, and lets OAL issue a determination (§11340.5(b)). Agencies explain how they read a rule without a comment period. This is fast and flexible, but harder to see coming. In California, if a "guideline" acts like a rule, anyone can ask OAL whether it is an "underground regulation." CBSC Information Bulletin 25-03 (Sep 22, 2025) explains the AB 130 code freeze (KOEB research notes). HUD's State and Local Best Practices (May 20, 2026) is nonbinding guidance under EO 14394.
4 Emergency orders and declarations Federal PREP Act, 42 U.S.C. §247d-6d(b)(1): the HHS Secretary may make a declaration "through publication in the Federal Register" covering "covered countermeasures." California emergency regulations, Gov. Code §11346.1: skip normal notice and comment on a written "finding of emergency" (b)(2), last 180 days unless the regular process is completed (e), with up to 2 readoptions of 90 days each (h). §11346.1(c): an emergency building standard is not effective unless the California Building Standards Commission approves it. Fast rules on a finding of emergency, with built-in expiry. The paper trail is the finding of emergency and the studies relied on, which §11346.1(b)(2) requires the agency to list. Hemp: CDPH's 2024 emergency regulations on THC in hemp food products, later followed by AB 8 (2025) ⚠ (regulation file not opened). Building: any emergency Title 24 change must go through CBSC under §11346.1(c). PREP Act: a health-countermeasure example only, not hemp or building.
5 Patents (USPTO) 35 U.S.C. §101 (what is patentable), §112(b) (claims must "particularly point out and distinctly claim") ⚠ not opened today A patent sets no public definition. It defines the edges of one owner's exclusive right. Its claims and "prior art" decide who may make what. A hemp-lime binder or panel method could be patented. Old public uses of hempcrete are prior art ⚠ (no specific patent checked).
6 Standards bodies (ICC, ASTM, NFPA) Private codes become law when adopted. Federally, through incorporation by reference, 5 U.S.C. §552(a)(1) and 1 CFR Part 51 ⚠ (1 CFR not opened). In California, the California Building Standards Commission (CBSC) adopts ICC model codes into Title 24 (KOEB research notes). ICC committees vote on model-code text. ASTM writes test methods. Governments then adopt them, sometimes with amendments, sometimes without some appendices. ICC 2024 IRC Appendix BL (Hemp-Lime) defines hemp-lime construction. California's 2025 CRC did not adopt it for dwellings; only SFM's §BL105 was adopted (KOEB research notes). BL105 points to ASTM E119 / UL 263 for fire ratings.

Who holds the pen, short version: - Lawmakers write statutes. - Agencies write rules (with comments) and guidance (without). - Governors and agencies write emergency rules (with expiry). - Private standards bodies write model text that governments adopt.

Tool 1: FOIA request (federal agency), "records behind a definition"

Submit through the agency's FOIA portal or FOIA.gov. Fill in the [brackets].

To: FOIA Officer, [Agency, e.g., USDA Agricultural Marketing Service / FDA] Re: Freedom of Information Act request, 5 U.S.C. §552

I request copies of the following records, created [start date] through the date of search, concerning how [agency] has defined or is defining "[term, e.g., industrial hemp / total THC / container]" under [authority, e.g., 7 U.S.C. §1639o as amended by P.L. 119-37 §781]:

  1. Draft definitions, decision memos, briefing papers, and options papers on the term.
  2. Guidance documents, FAQs, or internal instructions applying the term, final or draft.
  3. Public comments, petitions under 5 U.S.C. §553(e), and meeting logs or calendars of meetings with outside parties about the term.
  4. Communications with [other agency, e.g., FDA / USDA / state departments of agriculture] about the term.
  5. [For P.L. 119-37 §781(3)] records on the status of the FDA lists of naturally produced cannabinoids and the "container" information that the law required within 90 days of Nov 12, 2025.

Fee category: [individual / news media / educational]. I request a fee waiver because disclosure is in the public interest and not primarily commercial (5 U.S.C. §552(a)(4)(A)(iii)). If fees exceed $[X], please contact me first. Electronic records preferred. Please release reasonably segregable portions.

I understand the agency has 20 working days to determine whether to comply (5 U.S.C. §552(a)(6)(A)(i)). Thank you, [Name, contact]

Tool 2: CPRA request (California agency), "records behind a definition"

Example agencies: - HCD on why Appendix BL was not adopted - CDFA on its "total THC" testing definition - CBSC on IB 25-03

To: Public Records Coordinator, [Agency] Re: California Public Records Act request (Gov. Code §7920.000 et seq.)

I request copies of records, [start date] to present, showing how [agency] decided on [the definition, adoption, or non-adoption, e.g., "the decision not to adopt ICC 2024 IRC Appendix BL in the 2025 California Residential Code"], including:

  1. The rulemaking file or initial and final statements of reasons, or the finding of emergency if one was used (Gov. Code §11346.1(b)(2)), and any studies relied on.
  2. Staff memos, matrices, decision papers, or emails analyzing the item.
  3. Public comments received and the agency's responses.
  4. Any guideline, bulletin, or FAQ applying the definition, and the date it issued.

If no record exists for an item, please say so. Please release any reasonably segregable portions (Gov. Code §7922.525(b)) and respond within 10 days (§7922.535(a)). Electronic copies preferred. Thank you, [Name, contact]

⚠ items

✂ Your one action

Pick one definition that affects you, find which channel set it, and send the matching FOIA or records request template this week.

Scalable Manufacturing Cluster Model, Starting from California. See all 14 tools →

General information, not legal advice. You file in your own name. ⚠ = not verified from a primary page yet. Every tracker item is a lead to verify, not proof.