Tools for the People › Law A

The 22-month federal election records rule (52 U.S.C. §20701–20706): one-page explainer + CPRA request template

KOEB Tools for the People · built Nov 2, 2026 (PT). Not legal advice. ⚠ = not verified from a primary page.

Who it's for: Anyone asking how their county keeps federal election records. Your one action: This week, send the records request template on this page to your county Registrar of Voters, then write "Day 10" on your calendar.


What's really going on

Tina Peters' defense has cited a 1960 federal law that makes election officials keep federal election records for 22 months. The law is real, short, and narrow: - It says keep the records. - It punishes willfully destroying or altering them. - It lets only the U.S. Attorney General demand to inspect them.

Courts have now read it in two settings: - Her Colorado criminal case. The appeals court held the law does not create a duty to investigate, and found she had already met the duty to preserve. - DOJ's 2025–26 suits for state voter rolls. Several federal district courts have read "records" narrowly. Those appeals are pending.

A citizen cannot use §20703 to make anyone produce records. A citizen can ask their own county, under California's Public Records Act, how it complies. The template below does that.

The law, in plain words (text: govinfo, U.S. Code 2023 ed., Title 52 ch. 207, opened Nov 2, 2026)

Source: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USCODE-2023-title52/html/USCODE-2023-title52-subtitleII-chap207.htm

All six sections come from Pub. L. 86-449, title III (Civil Rights Act of 1960), May 6, 1960, 74 Stat. 88.

Section What it says (quoted or close paraphrase) Plain words
§20701 Every "officer of election" shall "retain and preserve, for a period of twenty-two months" from any federal general, special, or primary election "all records and papers which come into his possession relating to any application, registration, payment of poll tax, or other act requisite to voting." A state may name a custodian. Willful failure: fine up to $1,000, up to 1 year, or both. Keep federal-election paperwork 22 months.
§20702 Anyone who "willfully steals, destroys, conceals, mutilates, or alters" a §20701 record: same penalty. Don't destroy or tamper with it.
§20703 Records must be made available "upon demand in writing by the Attorney General or his representative," with "a statement of the basis and the purpose therefor." Only the AG (DOJ) can demand them under this law.
§20704 DOJ may not disclose produced records except to Congress, government agencies, or courts and grand juries, unless a U.S. court orders otherwise. DOJ must keep them confidential.
§20705 The U.S. district court where the demand is made, or where the records are, can compel production. Federal court enforces an AG demand.
§20706 "Officer of election" means anyone who performs any function "in connection with any application, registration... or other act requisite to voting" in a federal election. Clerks, registrars, and their staff.

Who enforces it: - §20703 and §20705 give the inspection-and-compel power to the Attorney General. - §20701 and §20702 are federal misdemeanors, prosecuted by DOJ. - Nothing in chapter 207 gives private citizens a right to demand records. Their route is state public-records law.

California's own, broader version (leginfo, opened Nov 2, 2026): - Elections Code §17301: for federal elections, ballots, paper cast vote records, vote-by-mail envelopes, provisional envelopes, and spoiled and canceled ballots must be kept "unopened and unaltered, for 22 months." - Elections Code §17303: tally sheets, challenge lists, and assisted-voter lists, also 22 months. "All voters may inspect the contents... following commencement of the official canvass." - Elections Code §17300: rosters and voter lists, 5 years. - Elections Code §17601 (amended by SB 1418, Stats. 2026 ch. 341, effective Sep 19, 2026): all voting-system, adjudication, and e-poll-book electronic data, HASH values, and ballot images, kept "stored and unaltered, for 22 months" in a sealed container. - Elections Code §17603: a chain-of-custody breach must be reported to the SOS within 24 hours. - Colorado's parallel rule (25 months for paper ballots, C.R.S. §1-7-802) is noted in the Peters opinion, fn. 2.

What courts have said (public record)

1. People v. Peters, 2026COA24, Colo. App. No. 24CA1951 (Apr 2, 2026). Opinion PDF: https://www.coloradojudicial.gov/system/files/opinions-2026-04/24CA1951-PD.pdf - ¶¶ 63–64: §20701 does not give Supremacy Clause immunity to a state officer. "Peters cites no case, nor are we aware of any, in which Supremacy Clause immunity has been extended to a state officer acting pursuant to a federal statute." - ¶ 98: "before the Build, Brown had already made several backups of the election records... she had fulfilled her duty as Clerk and Recorder to preserve the election records days before the Build." - ¶ 103: "by their plain language, neither § 20701 nor § 20702 imposes any duty on the election official to investigate the destruction of such records." - ¶ 113: the execution-of-public-duty defense was not available because her charged acts were not taken to preserve records that were already preserved. - The Colorado Supreme Court denied review on Sep 21, 2026 (No. 2026SC332) ⚠ (per KOEB research notes; order not opened directly). - A U.S. Supreme Court petition was announced but has not been filed ⚠.

2. United States v. Weber, C.D. Cal. No. 2:25-cv-09149-DOC-ADS (Jan 15, 2026), 816 F. Supp. 3d 1168. Order: https://www.cacd.uscourts.gov/sites/default/files/031146761135.pdf - Dismissed DOJ's suit for California's unredacted voter file. - Held DOJ's §20703 "statement of the basis and the purpose" was "both lacking in depth and is contrived." - The appeal is 9th Cir. No. 26-1232, argued May 19, 2026. No decision was found as of Nov 2, 2026 ⚠.

3. Other district courts. These are cited in DOJ's own 9th Cir. letter. ⚠ Not opened directly; letter via democracydocket.com. - U.S. v. Thomas (D. Conn., Jul 17, 2026) - U.S. v. Adams (E.D. Ky., Jul 23, 2026) - U.S. v. Caldwell (D.N.J., Jul 29, 2026) - U.S. v. Matthews (C.D. Ill., Jul 31, 2026)

Per DOJ's letter, these held a statewide voter registration list is not a Title III "record" because officials create it rather than receive it. Appeals are pending in the 6th Cir. (No. 26-5657) and 2d Cir. (No. 26-2064).

Where views differ (in their own words; questions to test)

Questions to test: 1. Which records "come into [an officer's] possession" under §20701, and which are created by the office? 2. Does copying or imaging a server count as preserving it? Does a software update that overwrites logs count as altering? 3. Who checks California counties' §17301 and §17601 compliance between elections?

Tool: CPRA request to your county elections office (template)

Send to your county's Registrar of Voters or clerk. Use their public-records portal or email. Fill in the [brackets].

To: [County] Registrar of Voters / Public Records Officer, [address or email] From: [Your name, contact] Date: [date] Re: California Public Records Act request (Gov. Code §7920.000 et seq.): retention of records from the [Nov 5, 2024 General / most recent federal] election

Under the California Public Records Act, Gov. Code §7920.000 et seq., I request copies of the following records, or, where no record exists, a statement saying so:

  1. Any written retention schedule, policy, or procedure your office uses to comply with Elections Code §§17301, 17303, 17305 and 17601, and with 52 U.S.C. §20701, for the [election] election.
  2. Records showing the planned or actual destruction or recycling date for that election's ballot packages and for electronic media under §17601. Examples: a disposition log, destruction certificate, or calendar entry.
  3. Chain-of-custody logs for the sealed containers of electronic media described in Elections Code §17601(b)(2) for that election, with any personal voter information redacted.
  4. Any notice your office sent to the Secretary of State under Elections Code §17603(b) for that election, or a statement that none exists.
  5. Any designation of a records "custodian" under 52 U.S.C. §20701 or state law for these records.

I am not asking for voted ballots, voter signatures, or any personal voter data, and I am not asking you to open any sealed package.

Electronic copies are preferred. If any part is withheld, please cite the exemption and release the rest (Gov. Code §7922.525(b), "reasonably segregable portion"). Please respond within 10 days as required by Gov. Code §7922.535(a). If you need more time, please give the reason and the expected date (§7922.535(b)). If fees over $[25] apply, please tell me first.

Thank you, [Name]

Tips: - §17303(c) already lets any voter inspect tally sheets and challenge lists after the canvass starts. You can ask to inspect in person. - Keep a copy and note the date sent. The 10-day clock starts at receipt.

⚠ items

✂ Your one action

This week, send the records request template on this page to your county Registrar of Voters, then write "Day 10" on your calendar.

Scalable Manufacturing Cluster Model, Starting from California. See all 14 tools →

General information, not legal advice. You file in your own name. ⚠ = not verified from a primary page yet. Every tracker item is a lead to verify, not proof.